It’s been years now since you smiled at me through the pre-pubescent and clammy hallway, and since I smiled back. I built our friendship on this smile, and others that I demanded from you as I shared what made me happy. I built our friendship on the ideals that we were the same and that you enjoyed my company, and I enjoyed yours. We listened to the same music and laughed at similar things; I cried with you over the deaths of loved ones and got angry with you when the other girls made snide comments. I built our friendship with you, on the smile that was once flashed from across a clammy hallway.
Now, when I look back to memories once lived, I recognise that this was not a simple smile shown to a stranger from the opposite side of an unknown area; this was not a welcoming and inviting ‘hello’ that made me feel warm to my core. In fact, it was snarky, it was arrogant, and it was insincere. Since that exchange, our whole friendship has followed the same theme. What was masquerading as kind or loving, was actually quite depraved. With you I’ve shared news of varying natures, and you have listened along, but you have never loved me completely. You say you love me, and you show me affection, but your heart is wandering to some other place during any hug, so that I am left feeling as though you may not even have one at all.
We can’t be friends anymore because I am not sure that you are capable of love. I have heard you say it, but only in the context of primary caregivers of which you are expected to love. I have seen you write it in cards or texts, and claim it quite a few times, but I have never observed genuine love in your eyes. I am an emotional human being, that feels deeper than is healthy, and you, where the cages of your heart should fall to show any true feelings, instead there is a cloudy glass wall that stifles any real cultivation. I am left asking myself if you are numb, and this makes me uncomfortable. We can’t be friends anymore because I am not sure I can understand a person who sounds like they have tape over their mouth every time they speak about a feeling. It sounds like you are suffocating, and if you are not, you are terribly empty.
We can’t be friends anymore because you hate my success. Sometimes you run over and beam with happiness, you must have received good news. When you reach me you will tell me that you got high distinctions for your class that you’ve been working hard on, and I will smile back and hug you with enthusiasm (because I can feel real emotion). I will bask in your success and share it with you because I feel as invested as you. But you do not return this sort of reaction, my friend. When I scurry over with my high distinction you flash your cloudy glassed smile, raise your eyebrows in uniform fashion and say ‘that’s good’. Every, single, time. Following this you turn to your left and then you go silent. There is no other discussion and I am left feeling sorry that I achieved. I am sorry my success hurts you, and that you can’t give me what I give to you in terms of genuine spirits. And because of this, we can’t be friends anymore.
We can’t be friends anymore because the snide smile that began the very foundations for which this friendship is based, makes me remove any future trust that I may have in you. Because the realisation that this was scripted makes me wonder if any moment I have ever shared with you is honest. You were young then, and so was I. I am so prepared to disregard that moment, accept that you may have learned and progressed. Yet, the other day I turned and saw you give this very same smile to a girl that you have expressed your disgust for on many occasions. Then it hit me, your mouth curved in the same way it did for me, your head tilted to the left just the same, and your eyes reached the same level of squint that I was granted; and for this, we can’t be friends anymore.